Is it worth grading Carmine - 217/167?

SV06: Twilight Masquerade · 217/167

Yes — if it grades 10. A 9 loses money at current prices. You need the 10. 9s are pooled across graders here — PriceCharting has no PSA-9-only figure.
RAW NOW$53.08TCGplayer market
PSA 10 SOLD$159.0021 completed sales
Grade 9 SOLD$63.9818 completed sales · mixed graders
IF IT GRADES 10+$81after $25 fee

A raw Carmine - 217/167 from SV06: Twilight Masquerade currently sells for about $53.08. Across 21 completed eBay sales, a PSA 10 has a median price of $159.00. After a $25 grading fee, a 10 would net roughly $80.92. But a Grade 9 (mixed graders) has a median of $63.98 across 18 sales — which works out to −$14.10 after fees. A 9 loses money at current prices. You need the 10. 9s are pooled across graders here — PriceCharting has no PSA-9-only figure.

Every grade, with the sales behind it

GRADEMEDIANSALES ON RECORD
PSA10$159.0021 sales
CGC10P$300.009 sales
CGC10$94.5012 sales
TAG10$180.005 sales
ACE10$124.424 sales
GRADE9.5$78.007 sales
GRADE9$63.9818 sales
GRADE8$60.0010 sales
GRADE7$60.006 sales

Now find a raw one to buy

Knowing a card is worth grading is the easy half. PokeSnipez watches eBay around the clock and flags raw copies of this card closing below market — so you can actually make the trade, not just read about it.

See live grade snipes →

Every figure on this page is an observed number. Raw prices come from TCGplayer; graded medians are completed eBay sales, shown with the sale count behind each one. We don't estimate, model, or fill in gaps — if a grade has no sales on record, it isn't listed. Grading outcomes are not guaranteed: most raw cards do not come back a 10, which is exactly why the 9-grade number is on this page. Where PriceCharting has no PSA-9-only figure we show its pooled 9 — PSA, BGS, CGC and SGC together — and label it as such rather than call it a PSA 9.